On February 6th 2008 48-year-old Judy Petty was working as a full-time caregiver for her grandmother in Parkersburg, WV. That day she left their home to return some books and DVDs to the library. Judy owned a car but preferred to travel by foot around town. Judy never returned home. On February 9th 2008 her mortal remains, charred and crumpled, were found in the burned out basement of an out building on her family's rural farm. To this day no one is certain whether or not her death was a homicide or a tragic accident. You be the judge.